|
An effective thinker has a wide range
of skills that help them to create meaning, gain understanding, make
judgments, make good decisions, self analyse and reflect. there are many
lists of skills available, and there is also much debate about what the
skills of an effective thinker are.
Considering the large and growing list
of
thinking skills , it seems that
amongst this large group of skills there must be some that we would
consider as being base or foundational skills. These are the skills
that we would not to ensure that we equip our pupils with.
Now obviously
there is no one right answer to this question and it is one that could
be debated extensively. As I consider the question I have a short list
of skills that I currently consider as crucial basic skills. These may
well change as my own understanding and knowledge deepens. Watch this
space.!
There are many
approaches one could use to find the answer to this question. Each
approach could well provide a different answer.
The method I used
to arrive at this list was to think of a problem solving situation and
then to identify the simple essentials of the process that would take a
person through to establishing a workable solution. This would give us
10 broad skills that we could start to concentrate on.
Essential or
Basic Thinking Skills:
-
Recognise a need or problem
-
Recognise inadequate information or
evidence
-
Clarify relevant language
-
Ask relevant questions
-
Differentiate between fact and
opinion
-
Evaluate credibility of information
& sources
-
Generating solutions
-
Assessing solutions
-
Consider long and short term
consequences, sequels and outcomes
-
Make wise decisions
Of course some of
these are fairly broad skills and many actually include further skills
sets in their own right.
I suppose an
interesting sub-question would be… “Is there one central skill that is
absolutely vital?”
For myself I
would consider the skill of questioning to be central to the whole
exercise of effective thinking. I would agree with Edward De Bono who
states that “Questioning is the engine house of thinking”. It seems to
me that without the ability to ask effective, relevant and probing
questions then thinking itself would cease to be effective.
Another approach
that I have used with schools is to look at the Inquiry Learning
process that the school is using and determine which thinking skills
match with each part of the inquiry process. When we examine the
SAUCE model we get the possible
answer to the question of basic skills, again it is still a debatable
answer.
Setting
the Scene
Skills: Clarify relevant language, Clarify
issues, Ask relevant questions
Acquiring
Information
Evaluate validity/credibility of information &
sources, Clarify and critique texts,
Weigh evidence, Ask relevant questions
Using
the Information
Make wise decisions, Consider long and short
term possible outcomes and consequences,
Assess possible solutions, Generating
solutions, Ask relevant questions
Communicating
outcome, thinking and decisions
Ask relevant questions
Rather than try
and identify further specific thinking skills for this stage we felt it
was more relevant to point from here towards the schools documentation
on communication skills… which will also have thinking skills embedded.
Evaluating
product and process
Ask relevant questions, Analyse and evaluate
actions
Again there is
the very obvious factor that questioning seems to be a central skill.
We also end up
with a very similar set of base skills with only a couple of variations.
-
Ask relevant questions
-
Clarify relevant language,
-
Clarify issues,
-
Evaluate validity/credibility of
information & sources,
-
Clarify and critique texts,
-
Weigh evidence,
-
Make wise decisions,
-
Consider long and short term
possible outcomes and consequences,
-
Assess possible solutions,
-
Generating solutions,
-
Analyse and evaluate actions
I
believe it is important for schools to spend some time deciding what
skills they see as being central or core to thinking. If you do this it
gives you some solid targets to aim at. I have a strong suspicion that
many schools have decided that thinking is important, state they they
will address thinking skills, and then fail to take this on to the
development of an effective programme that deliberately targets specific
skills and attitudes. |